Unusual Economic Indicators and also How They Predict Economic Downturns

Want to realize whether a recession is coming? You could ask an economist. Or you may take a look at underclothes income.

It’s relatively hard to evaluate whether we’re approximately to enter a duration of bad monetary boom the use of traditional information. Prominent economists polled through the Wall Street Journal in October placed the possibility of a recession within the next 12 months at anywhere from 1% to a hundred%. With professional opinion so divided, may want to oddball recession indicators like lipstick income and whether the Phillies won the World Series offer added insight?

Here’s a observe a number of the unconventional monetary signs and what they presently say approximately whether a recession is at the way.

Key Takeaways
Sales of fellows’s underwear, the length of skirts, the popularity of Spam, and Philly sports titles have all been used to gauge the well being of the U.S. Financial system.
Unconventional indicators offer an alternative to professional predictions of recession, which might be often divided.
Upon near scrutiny, oddball signs are of little use in relation to predicting a coming recession.
A Brief(s) Glance on the Economy
If men’s underwear income are falling, the financial system can also be happening the tubes—that’s the principle anyway.

When humans are below monetary stress, they reduce lower back at the least necessary items first. Supposedly, this means guys will hold their present underclothes in provider longer than they commonly would.

The idea comes from longtime Federal Reserve chairman Alan Greenspan, who would reportedly take the economic system’s temperature by looking for moderate variations in guys’s undies income. That’s consistent with former NPR economics reporter Robert Krulwich, who heard the concept from Greenspan and explained the reasoning behind it in a 2007 interview:

“The garment this is the maximum personal is the male underpant, due to the fact nobody sees it besides human beings like, inside the locker room, and who cares?” Krulwich said. “The last purchase that you don’t need to make is underpants.”1

If that theory truely holds genuine, the global financial system might be in problem. In the 0.33 area of 2022, Hanes pronounced an eleven% year-over-year drop in innerwear sales, which incorporates guys’s and girls’s underwear, socks, and shapewear. Hanes’ file stated the drop in sales turned into in part because of “macroeconomic pressures that weighed on purchaser spending.”2

Paying Lip Service

When the going receives tough, the tough buy greater lipstick—or so the “Lipstick Index” concept of recession prediction might advise.

The lipstick idea likely is going back to the 2001 recession, whilst Leonard Lauder, CEO of make-up logo Estée Lauder, informed the Wall Street Journal that lipstick income tend to upward push in times of hassle. Unlike dresses or jewelry, lipstick is an “affordable luxurious” that human beings can bask in while money is tight.Three


If you’re searching out the Lipstick Index to provide readability wherein hard data is murky, you’re out of luck.: There’s no legitimate authorities facts on lipstick sales, and private sources are mixed.

Earlier this yr, the Lipstick Index changed into off the charts, flashing loud recession alarms, in line with market studies company The NPD Group, which tracks lipstick sales. Sales had been up 48% 12 months-over-year in the first zone. But as NPD stated, the lifting of mask mandates and social distancing guidelines at that time may also have had something to do with the surprising recognition of makeup.4

However, as of September, increase in lipstick sales had bogged down significantly over the previous three months, market studies company NielsenIQ stated in a report. That casts doubt over the complete “Lipstick Index” principle, Nielsen stated.

“As the danger of recession looms, lipstick income have dropped,” Nielsen analysts wrote in a observation. “It now appears that the ‘Lipstick Index’ principle may additionally no longer practice to the Beauty and Personal Care enterprise.”five

The file did not cope with some other possible interpretation: The Lipstick Index is efficiently showing a deep recession is not going, as a few economists additionally consider.

Spam, Spam, Spam, Spam

If you want to recognize whether the financial system is headed for a prolonged dip, then the quantity of Spam cans for your pantry is a sign things are horrific, consistent with the Spam theory.

With a 12-ounce can of the canned pork promoting for just $three.Fifty eight at Walmart, Spam is a exceedingly inexpensive supply of protein. So an awful lot so that in the 2008 recession, stock analysts noted that Hormel, the maker of Spam and different canned items, saw inventory returns and profitability boom beyond pre-recession tiers.67

During the depths of the Great Recession in 2008, Hormel personnel have been operating beyond regular time to supply the nation with Spam, in line with a document from the New York Times. Spam changed into among a listing of thrifty grocery items promoting properly inside the downturn, the Times said, mentioning statistics from marketing firm Information Resources.8

There’s just one hassle: These days, Spam seems to sell well no matter what the economy is doing. Spam income broke data for seven years walking as of 2021, consistent with Hormel—a duration that blanketed years of robust monetary increase, in addition to a short pandemic-caused recession in early 2020.9

So tons for the Spam index.

A Fashionable Indicator

In 1926, economist George Taylor suggested that the nation of the economic system inspired girls’s fashion. In flourishing instances, skirts got shorter because women desired to reveal off the expensive silk stockings they might afford to shop for. In downturns, hemlines were given longer because ladies did now not have the cash for expensive stockings and that they wanted to cover the dearth thereof.10

The motive for the intended correlation got shakier with the adoption of reasonably-priced nylon stockings within the 1940s. It faded in addition nevertheless inside the Nineteen Sixties and past, while more women commenced ditching skirts and attire for pants. Nevertheless, the so-referred to as “Hemline Index” has stoked researchers’ interest over time.

In 2010, a couple of Dutch researchers analyzed statistics from the National Bureau of Economic Research and measured hem lengths from a French fashion magazine. They concluded that hemlines did circulate with the economy as Taylor had suggested, however at a lag of 3 years.11

In different words, it’s no longer so much that women’s style predicts the state of the economy, but that the state of the economic system predicts ladies’s fashion. That became also the belief a duo of researchers at the University of Georgia and the University of South Korea reached in 2015 when they posted a paper noting skirts and dresses, as shown in images from Vogue Magazine, were given longer when recessions hit. Consistent with their principle, their information showed hemlines getting shorter beginning in 2010 because the economy recovered from the Great Recession.12

The takeaway: The Hemline Index can’t let you know if a recession is coming, but a recession would possibly let you know loads approximately the future of skirt lengths—true statistics to have in case you’re in the textile commercial enterprise.

“This statistical device can be very beneficial to fashion groups who need to make design selections concerning hemline lengths at least a 12 months in advance of releasing a line,” the researchers wrote.Thirteen

A Phishy Philly Connection

When the Philadelphia Phillies win the World Series, the financial system loses. That’s the belief of the Phillies Index.

Philadelphia baseball groups have handiest ever gained international championships for the duration of instances of economic complication: 2008 (the Great Recession), 1980 (recession), and 1929 and 1930 (the Great Depression).1415

The Astros beat the Phillies in the 2022 series. Don’t breathe easy pretty yet, even though, even if you believe in this superstitious indicator. Plenty of recessions over the last century have come and gone with out a Philly baseball championship—maximum currently the 2020 COVID-19 recession and the 2001 recession.

Related Posts